when you say "click" do you mean from the starter itself or is the click comming from the relay. do you get the same results and sounds using a jumper wire as you do your key. all your key does (on the starting part) is send a positive charge to the s terminal to cause the relay to close and send power directly from the battery to the starter. if the jumper wire yeilds the same results its most likely not the key/ ignition switch. see if auto zone will warranty swap your relay, and it might be time to test your starter assuming the battery terminals are clean and tight,the cables are not all corroded and dont have crazy hight resistance and the engine is wel grounded. and i would pick up volt meter soon, it would make this easier and it will pay for itself in the future, very handy tool.