Well I went to a JY and picked up a BOO from a F-350. Installed it and it was far worse than before! Brake pedal was almost to the floor before the lights came on.
Well I was wondering where I went wrong and started to think that maybe it was a 250 not a 350, and I grabbed the wrong part or something.
Then I read this:
I found that you can install the switch upside down and cause what you are describing (don't ask how I know :doh0715

Use the diagram provided by Steve83 to make sure yours is installed properly.
Works great now. :doh0715:
Here are picks of the two different BOO switches:
Original on right. f350 on left
Other side, F350 on bottom
I know its an old thread, but its useful, and I added pictures!