I agree with this. If you plan to be offroad a lot and not moving very fast then mechanical is a much better choice as it is simple and wont easily fail. However if you want more space up front or wont be offroad at very much then electric will work well. Just dont be 200miles from anything in the desert because if the electric fans fail youll be in some trouble. In conclusion. If your offroading like mad max use a mechanical fan. If your a street warrior use electric or mechanical its really personal preference.I had that issue in my f150, I just put a small fan spacer on. I’ve never seen electric fans beat the cooling of properly sized and shrouded mechanical fans. I’m sure others have electric fans that work good, but in my experience there is eventually a reliability issue with electric fans